Everton and Chelsea arrive level on 10 points, Everton 5th and Chelsea 6th. Everton come in unbeaten in their last five (two wins, three draws) and hard to break down at home — two wins and a draw in their three league games there, conceding just twice. Chelsea carry the bigger threat up front, with five past Bournemouth and six past Leeds in recent weeks, but they have lost two of their last three on the road, shipping seven goals across three away league games and drawing a blank in a 0–3 defeat at Brentford. In this exact fixture Everton have won three of the last five home meetings with Chelsea, who were kept out in four of them, and Everton won it 3–0 here last season. Post-international break, so no midweek fatigue and no suspensions either way.
Probable shape: 4-2-3-1 — Pickford; Tarkowski & Branthwaite anchoring the back line; Garner and Dewsbury-Hall (scored and assisted at Hull) in midfield, Grealish wide, Barry leading the line, Everton's top scorer.
Probable front line: Joao Pedro, Cole Palmer, Morgan Rogers and Pedro Neto — the group driving Chelsea's scoring run under Xabi Alonso.
| Date | Home | Score | Away | BTTS | Goals |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 21 Mar 2026 | Everton | 3–0 | Chelsea | No | 3 |
| 22 Dec 2024 | Everton | 0–0 | Chelsea | No | 0 |
| 10 Dec 2023 | Everton | 2–0 | Chelsea | No | 2 |
| 06 Aug 2022 | Everton | 0–1 | Chelsea | No | 1 |
| 01 May 2022 | Everton | 1–0 | Chelsea | No | 1 |
Across all venues the last five meetings read very differently — Chelsea three wins, Everton one, one draw, including a 6–0 at Stamford Bridge, at an average of 2.4 goals a game. The low-scoring, Everton-leaning pattern is a home-venue effect, not a whole-rivalry one. Everton moved to Hill Dickinson Stadium in 2025; the 3–0 last March was the first meeting there.
| Market | Outcome | Verdict | Odds | My Assessment |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chelsea team goals | Under 1.5 | Good Bet | 1.87 | 59% |
| Total goals | Under 3.5 | Good Bet | 1.51 | 71% |
| Draw no bet | Everton | Good Bet | 2.30 | 47% |
| Match result | Everton win | Good Bet | 3.24 | 36% |
| Double chance | Everton or draw | Good Bet | 1.66 | 61% |
| Everton clean sheet | Yes | Good Bet | 4.30 | 26% |
| Both teams to score | No | Good Bet | 2.35 | 45% |
| Everton team goals | Everton to score | Solid Pick | 1.32 | 74% |
| Double chance | No draw (Eve or Che) | Solid Pick | 1.29 | 75% |
| Total goals | Under 2.5 | Speculative | 2.25 | 49% |
| Match scorers | Only Everton to score | Speculative | 6.10 | 19% |
| Chelsea clean sheet | No | Speculative | 1.30 | 76% |
| Everton team goals | Under 1.5 | No edge | 1.56 | 62% |
| Score + result | Both score, a team wins | No edge | 2.25 | 43% |
| Match result | Chelsea win | Avoid | 2.23 | 39% |
| Match result | Draw | Avoid | 3.81 | 26% |
| Total goals | Over 2.5 | Avoid | 1.68 | 52% |
| Both teams to score | Yes | Avoid | 1.60 | 56% |
| Chelsea clean sheet | Yes | Avoid | 3.33 | 25% |
Chelsea were kept out in four of the last five visits to Everton, with Everton keeping a clean sheet in each. Pair that with Everton conceding just twice in three home league games and a Chelsea side that has lost two of its last three away — blanked 0–3 at Brentford — and keeping them to one goal or none is the standout call on the card.
This home fixture has averaged 1.4 goals a game and gone over 2.5 only once in the last five here. Everton are low-volume in attack and tight at the back at home, and the match-up keeps producing tight, low totals. Four goals or more would run against everything this specific fixture gives at Everton.
Everton are unbeaten in their last five, have won three of the last five home meetings with Chelsea and lost only one, and beat them 3–0 here last season. The market makes Chelsea favourites on their attacking form, which is where the value on the home side on the draw-no-bet comes from — your stake comes back if it finishes level.
All five of the last home meetings in this fixture finished both-teams-to-score No. Everton tend to find a goal while Chelsea are the side far more likely to be blanked here, having been kept out in four of the last five visits. The price at 2.35 is generous for a pattern this one-sided.
The boldest version of the same read: Everton kept a clean sheet in four of the last five home games against Chelsea and have conceded only twice at home this season. At 4.30 the price more than covers the risk, but this is the higher-variance pick — it needs Chelsea's in-form attack shut out completely.
Our assessment puts this at 74% — a high-confidence outcome. Chelsea have conceded in every one of their recent games and Everton have scored in most of theirs. The price is fair, so there is no edge to chase, but this is the steadiest leg for an accumulator.
Our assessment puts a decisive result at 75%. Four of the last five home meetings in this fixture were settled one way rather than shared, and the price is about right — no real edge, but a dependable leg if you want to shorten an acca with a steady selection.
The venue record (1.4 goals a game, under 2.5 in four of the last five here) points clearly this way. The reason it is only speculative rather than a stronger call is the obvious counter: Chelsea's own recent games have been high-scoring, with five and six-goal returns in the mix.
Higher bar applies to totals markets — this clears speculative but not the stronger tiers because of Chelsea's scoring form.
The exact "Everton win to nil" shape this fixture keeps producing — three of the last five here were 1–0, 2–0 or 3–0 to Everton. At 6.10 it is a longer-odds expression of the clean-sheet read, worth a small stake rather than a main pick.
Longer price, higher variance — it needs Everton to score and Chelsea to be shut out in the same game.
These markets were assessed and found fairly priced — no meaningful edge identified:
These outcomes are overpriced against our read — we recommend skipping:
Confidence is held at Medium. The read is coherent and well-supported by the home head-to-head record and both sides' recent form, but the one flagged item is a real divergence: the market rates Chelsea favourites on their scoring form while the venue pattern and Chelsea's away record point the other way. Early in the season that divergence keeps every pick at Medium at most — no outcome qualifies as a top-tier call.